The Small Town in New York That Feels Straight Out of Stranger Things

Ever wondered where Stranger Things got its creepy government experiments and otherworldly creatures? Believe it or not, the inspiration comes from a real place: Montauk. This small town in New York, located at the tip of Long Island, has its own peculiar history that could give Hawkins, Indiana, a run for its money.

The show was actually almost called Montauk, and the Duffer Brothers originally planned to set it in this coastal town. They were fascinated by local legends about Camp Hero State Park, and they loved that Montauk carried the same coastal suspense you get from Jaws. When production in Montauk proved impractical, they shifted the setting to the fictional town of Hawkins, Indiana (filming took place in Georgia). Even so, Montauk’s mysterious past still shaped the show’s weird and wonderful ideas.

So, what’s the deal with Montauk? It all comes down to something known as the Montauk Project. According to conspiracy theories and urban legends, this was a secret government program at Camp Hero, a decommissioned military base, back in the 70s and 80s. Stories—popularized in a 1990s book by Preston Nichols—claim the experiments involved mind control, time travel, and even opening portals to other dimensions. Sound familiar? For locals, it’s a mix of myth and unsettling rumor, but for fans of the supernatural, it’s the kind of tale that sparks the imagination.

Today, Camp Hero State Park covers 415 acres of forest, wetlands, and beaches. It’s a popular place for hikers, birdwatchers, and nature lovers. Despite all the natural beauty, the old military buildings and massive radar tower still stand, giving the park a slightly eerie atmosphere. Wander the trails, snap a photo by the radar station, and let your imagination run wild thinking about the secrets that might have been hidden here decades ago. It’s the perfect place to channel your inner Stranger Things character. The striking contrast between the park’s natural landscapes and abandoned structures makes it feel like an authentic set from the show’s universe.

Of course, Montauk is more than just its spooky stories. This fishing village is quiet in the winter but buzzing in the summer. It’s known for its relaxed vibe and incredible seafood—Harvest on Fort Pond is a standout—and wide sandy beaches like Kirk Park Beach. Montauk Point Lighthouse, commissioned by George Washington in 1792, is a must-visit. Climb to the top for sweeping views of the Atlantic Ocean, then stick around for a stroll along the rocky coastline.

If you’re planning a visit, start your day at Camp Hero. There’s a small parking fee during peak season, but the park has plenty of parking, and the trails are easy enough for most people. After exploring, reward yourself in town with a seafood feast. Lobster rolls, clam chowder, and freshly caught striped bass are local staples. Add in a cozy bed-and-breakfast stay at Sunrise Guest House, and you’ve got yourself a trip that blends mystery, history, and pure coastal charm.

Whether you’re into conspiracy theories, a die-hard Stranger Things fan, or just someone who loves a beautiful beach town with a little intrigue, Montauk delivers. The next time you watch the show, remember that its strange story started right here in this unassuming small town in New York. Sometimes reality is just as strange as fiction—and Montauk proves it. For more on exploring the area, check out Camp Hero State Park and learn more about the town at Visit Montauk.

Which small towns straight out of Stranger Things should we explore next? Share your pick by submitting it through our nomination form, and when you’re ready to plan your trip, use our itinerary planner to map out your adventure through this captivating town.