They say first impressions are everything, but in some cases, you shouldn’t form your impressions of a place based on its appearance. These 10 hole in the wall restaurants in Wyoming are the perfect examples. While the exteriors aren’t fancy, the food is absolutely delicious, and the service is stellar. These restaurants aren’t ranked in the list below, but rather listed alphabetically.
1. 2 Doors Down, Cheyenne
Delicious burgers and bottomless fries, combined with incredible service make 2 Doors Down a don’t-miss. 1802 Dell Range Blvd., Cheyenne.
Check out their incredible burgers!
2. Cowboy Cafe, Lyman
This little hole-in-the-wall cafe has a really diverse menu - and everything on it is tasty. Also...the best pies in the county! 2797 County Road 231, Lyman.
There’s a reason it’s one of our favorite small town spots.
3. J’s Prairie Rose Cafe, Laramie
You can’t go wrong with a single item on the menu, but the smothered burrito sure is good! 410 S. 2nd Street, Laramie.
Check out their website for more information.
4. Jody’s Diner, Evanston
It might be located in an old convenience store, but breakfast here is amazing! 260 Bear River Drive, Evanston.
Check out their website for more information.
5. La Cocina, Casper
From the outside, La Cocina doesn’t look like anything special, but the interior is nicely appointed and the food...to die for! 321 E. ‘E’ Street, Casper.
See why it made our list of top Mexican restaurants in Wyoming.
6. Miners and Stockman’s Steakhouse, Hartville
This is Wyoming’s oldest bar, but hiding inside you’ll find some of the best steaks in Wyoming. 608 Main Street, Hartville.
Read more about it right here.
7. Outpost Cafe, Lusk
Everything on the menu is good, but don’t miss the homemade pie. 1011 S Main Street, Lusk.
Follow them on Facebook, here, to keep tabs on hours and specials.
8. Papa Binos, Buffalo
This hole-in-the-wall offers more than just Mexican food - the breakfast is also good, and the dessert is out of this world! Of course, Mexican food is their speciality and they do it soooo well. 98 S. Main Street, Buffalo.
Follow them on Facebook, here, for more information.
9. Sushi Boat Restaurant
This sushi restaurant is attached to an old motel, but don’t be too quick to judge...the sushi is amazing. Yelp reviewers give it high ratings overall, and the free miso soup is delicious. 421 Boswell Drive, Laramie.
Find our more by following their Facebook page, here.
10. Winchester Steakhouse, Buffalo a
The steaks here are soooo good, and they're gigantic! 117 U.S. Hwy 16 E., Buffalo.
Read more about this world-class steakhouse right here.
This list includes just 10 of Wyoming’s ‘hole in the wall’ restaurants! We know there are many, many more. What’s YOUR favorite?
Subscribe to our newsletter
Get the latest updates and news
Thank you for subscribing!