Want some filling food with an atmosphere that is just as good as what’s on the plate? Looking for authentic and timeless meals that make you want to ask for seconds—or even thirds? Looking for reliable flavor from dishes that are as good today as they were many decades ago? Then check out DeStefano’s Olde Erie, a restaurant in Middletown, New York that serves up classic Italian-American fare and more. It might just have the best Italian food in Middletown, New York. To learn more about this establishment, keep reading below.

DeStefano’s Olde Erie is a perfect spot for either lunch or dinner. The food featured at the establishment ranges from American classics to those Italian stapes that many can’t live without. There’s something for everyone here.
Evelyn F/Google Reviews
There are plenty of tasty pasta options available. Looking for pasta with meatballs? They have that at DeStefano’s. They also have pasta with a variety of sauces, among them, alfredo, bolognese, mushroom and more.
Kevin Eller/Google Reviews
At DeStefano’s, the portions are generous and the prices are right. Don’t want pasta? They also have a variety of salads and great appetizers. We recommend trying out the baked clams or the oysters Rockefeller—classic dishes that will start a meal the right way. Diners even could order a full sub platter!
Laura Bolle/Google Reviews

Related Stories

The Biscuits And Gravy From The Gem Diner In New York Are So Big, They Could Feed An Entire Family

The Biscuits And Gravy From The Gem Diner In New York Are So Big, They Could Feed An Entire Family

 The Small-Town Diner Where Locals Catch Up Over Pancakes

The Small-Town Diner Where Locals Catch Up Over Pancakes

 The Brand New Restaurant In New York That Locals Can't Get Enough Of

The Brand New Restaurant In New York That Locals Can't Get Enough Of
The menu here is massive, and full of delights. There are plenty of veal and chicken meals on offer, as well as great Italian specialties like baked lasagna and eggplant parmigiana. We haven’t even mentioned all the seafood yet!
Chad Patrick/Google Reviews
Then there are the steaks and chops—classy entrees that pair nicely with DeStefano’s classy dining room. Why not splurge and try the grilled rib eye, served with a soup or salad and choice of side.
Laura Bolle/Google Reviews
DeStefano’s has a fully stocked bar, so don’t be afraid to order a beer or cocktail with a meal, or enjoy a cup of coffee before taking off.
Dan & Charlie/Google Reviews
This Middletown staple makes for a great casual lunch or a slightly more formal dinner.
Armel/Google Reviews

For a great meal, be it Italian-American food or American staples, check out DeStefano’s Olde Erie. We definitely think it serves the best Italian food in Middletown, New York. While in the Hudson Valley area, why not check out this legally haunted house? It is spooky season, after all. And for those looking for a place to stay, we recommend the Holiday Inn Express & Suites.

OnlyInYourState may earn compensation through affiliate links in this article. As an Amazon Associate, we earn from qualifying purchases.

Related Articles

Explore New York

Featured Addresses
DeStefano's Olde Erie, 7 W Main St, Middletown, NY 10940, USA