Have you ever wondered what the best seafood restaurants in New Jersey are? It's a fair question, as the Garden State is home to some of the best seafood spots in the Mid Atlantic. From unassuming little clam shacks and massive all-you-can-eat seafood buffets to hole-in-the-wall spots serving fresh oysters to hidden gems dishing out the best lobster rolls in the world (sorry, Maine!), here are the best seafood restaurants in New Jersey for when the craving strikes for some fresh-off-the-boat fare.
1. The Old Causeway Steak & Oyster House, Manahawkin
This Jersey Shore staple was named "Best of the Shore" by Philadelphia Magazine, and it's no surprise why. The menu is extensive, the atmosphere is amazing, and the seafood is fresh and delicious.
2. Molos Restaurant, Weehawken
Molos Restaurant is a perennial Garden State favorite that serves amazing Greek seafood with incredible service and spectacular views. Open for brunch, lunch, and dinner, Molos also offers happy hour specials. Enjoy shrimp, salmon, lobster, crab, octopus and more.
3. Kunkel's Seafood & Steakhouse, Haddon Heights
Another New Jersey favorite, Kunkel's offers a full and varied menu, including a kid's menu, so you'll find something for everyone. The dessert selection is sizable, and if you're a fan of spicy foods, be sure to try the Fiery Thai Calamari.
4. Mike's Seafood, Sea Isle City
Humble and unassuming, this Jersey Shore staple was named "Best of the Shore" by Philadelphia Magazine, and it's no surprise why. The menu is extensive, the atmosphere is amazing, and the seafood is fresh and delicious.
5. Oceanos Oyster Bar and Seafood Grill, Fair Lawn
Another Greek seafood spot that's one of the best restaurants in the Garden State, Oceanos carries top-notch reviews on Yelp. Try the Shrimp Saganaki appetizer, Sampler Platter, and Vesuvius cake - five rich layers of chocolate and a thick layer of cheesecake. All we can say is, "Opa!" And yes, please.
6. Dockside Market & Grill, Flemington
Dockside Market & Grill offers a full menu AND fresh fish for purchase... plus super scenic waterfront dining. You'll love the charming atmosphere and flavorful dishes. Try the Fisherman's Platter for a little bit of everything.
7. Blue Claw Seafood & Crab Eatery, Burlington
You'll find affordable seafood, a casual atmosphere, and friendly service at this restaurant, which has won numerous "best of" awards. Try the crab meat mac n' cheese or buffalo garlic scallops if you're looking for something a little different.
8. Allegro Seafood Grill, Newark
This Portuguese seafood spot (yes -- in New Jersey!) has so much to offer. You'll enjoy quality food, a unique menu, live music, and a seasonal patio. Guests rave about great food, great service and sizable portions at this restaurant in New Jersey.
9. Uncle Vinnie's Clam Bar, Raritan
Though the menu is on the smaller side, everything at this clam shack in New Jersey is delicious. The place is often packed and the reviews are outstanding.
10. Skipper's Seafood, Barnegat
This seasonal market boasts a small shack, the "Sea Dogs Grill" for those looking for a more traditional dining experience. Less of a restaurant and more of a market, this is the perfect place to buy in bulk (perhaps for upcoming holiday feasts) as the prices are great and the seafood is fresh! Talk about stellar New Jersey seafood.
11. The Walpack Inn, Walpack Center
This rustic lodge with a gorgeous greenhouse for a dining room serves up a wide variety of American cuisine; the eatery is always included on the best seafood restaurants in New Jersey lists! Located on state parkland near the Delaware Water Gap and Worthington State Forest, guests will be surrounded by nature and can even rent a room at the cabin on the property.
12. Shore Fresh, Point Pleasant
Folks come from far and wide to try the lobster rolls at Shore Fresh in Point Pleasant, New Jersey. Some even say they rival those found in Maine! It's a bold claim, but we're not ones to argue with popular opinion, especially with regards to amazing New Jersey seafood.
13. The Milford House, Milford
Tucked away in one of our favorite little towns in New Jersey, the Milford House is a perennial favorite that's known for a sublime and savory combination of American comfort food, seafood, and raw oysters. Sign us up!
14. Steve & Cookies By The Bay, Margate City
This popular local and top-rated joint is big on community and taste. You'll love the friendly service, fresh seafood, and extensive dessert menu. We could go for a slice of brownie pie right now! Other favorites include blueberry pie, crab cakes and Warner's Bouillabaisse.
15. Maritime Parc, Jersey City
Located in Liberty State Park on the Hudson River, this modern seafood restaurant offers spectacular views and is a popular spot for private events. Guests will enjoy classic favorites with a contemporary twist and the Chef's Tasting Menus come highly recommended.
16. Shipwreck Grill, Brielle
Guests will enjoy a casual atmosphere and upscale menu at this top-rated restaurant. Accolades include being named a "best restaurant" by New Jersey Monthly and high ratings on Zagat and Yelp. Pictured is the Roasted Swordfish "Nicoise."
17. Oyster Creek Restaurant and Boat Bar, Leeds Point
This waterfront gem in New Jersey is home to the famous "boat bar" and has been featured on Diners, Drive-ins', and Dives. The food is exceptional and there is no better time to try it than right now! The holiday customer appreciation menu is a phenomenal deal offering guests select appetizer + salad + entree + dessert combinations for just $25 per person. This limited time offer is not available on Christmas or New Year's Eve. To learn more, visit OysterCreekInnNJ.com.
It's no surprise we have so many great seafood restaurants with our sizable coastline. What do you think -- are there any places you'd include on the above list of best seafood restaurants in New Jersey? Where do you go to satisfy a massive seafood craving? Any favorite seafood buffets in New Jersey you want to share? Sound off on all things Garden State seafood in the comments below!
Of course, it isn't all seafood all the time here in our beautiful state.. for proof of this, check out these high-rated and critically acclaimed restaurants in New Jersey!
Subscribe to our newsletter
Get the latest updates and news
Thank you for subscribing!