Mama said don't judge a book by its cover...but we do. I know I do that with restaurants. Which is silly, because you're there to eat, not to gaze at the interior design. These places might not look like the fanciest places in the world...but inside, they house some of the best culinary delights Wisconsin has to offer. So get ready to grab a napkin, because you're about to drool over these unassuming restaurants in Wisconsin:
Please note, The Comet Café and Delta Diner are temporarily closed.
1. Frank's Diner (Kenosha)
Frank's does Wisconsin food. Period. They've got those big breakfasts we're known for. But then there are pasties for our UP friends who have influenced us. And because it's Wisconsin, this diner is serving Bloody Marys. This place is for you! To learn more, visit the website for Frank's Diner.
2. The Comet Cafe (Milwaukee)
Editor's note: The Comet Café and Delta Diner is temporarily closed.
Do you have a comfort food craving? If so, you have to check out the Comet Cafe. They do a meatloaf that will bring you back. Don't eat meat? They have legitimately good vegetarian dishes as well. But they also do "Bacon Night." For the latest information, visit Comet Cafe's website.
3. Delta Diner (Delta)
It's pretty safe to say that Delta Diner is one of the few diners you'll find in the woods. This diner doesn't have a ton of offerings, but what they do, they do well. People are loving the burgers, and people have commented on the authenticity of the Norwegian cakes. Check out Delta Diner's website to learn more.
4. The Brick House Cafe (Cable)
What lies up the steps of this old house is some of the best food you'll find in Wisconsin. You can get an awesome breakfast. But then you can get a delectable sandwich (people rave about the 'heidi ho'). Visit The Brick House Cafe's website to learn more.
5. The Cozzy Corner (Appleton)
It's hard finding a decent soul food place in Wisconsin, but this place does it so well. People RAVE about the BBQ chicken, and I'm partial to the mac n' cheese. Visit The Cozzy Corner's website to learn more.
6. Shorty's Pizza and Smoked Meat (Superior)
Please note, Shorty's Pizza and Smoked Meat has permanently closed.
You wouldn't think that some of the best pizza in Wisconsin would be up in Superior...but it is. Meat lovers, rejoice! You can get meats piled on a pizza or in sandwich form. A must-dine for carnivores. To learn more, visit the website for Shorty's Pizza and Smoked Meat.
7. Wedl's Hamburger Stand (Jefferson)
Wedl's has been making the same hamburgers for over 100 years. They're thin, crispy, the kind that don't require much effort to eat. There's a reason these burgers have been selling for over a century. This unique little food stand is only open seasonally, so check their current hours before heading out. To learn more, visit Wedl's Hamburger Stand's website.
8. Monty's Blue Plate Diner (Madison)
This is a fantastic place where you can get breakfast all day. But the desserts are absolutely phenomenal. The pie is super good, and I'm in love with the sundaes. To learn more, check out the website for Monty's Blue Plate Diner.
Have you been to any of these unassuming restaurants in Wisconsin? Which one is your favorite? Share your thoughts with us in the comments below! And if we happened to leave off your favorite eatery, nominate it for a chance to be featured in a future article.
If you loved these places, check out this little-known Wisconsin BBQ restaurant that's tucked inside a gas station!
Subscribe to our newsletter
Get the latest updates and news
Thank you for subscribing!