It's time to talk about where in New York you can find a delicious pie, and no we're not talking pizza. We're here to talk about the light but filling pastry treat that we love seeing come in so many various ways. A baked dish that every region of our state loves to put their own spin on, so you can count on having a hard time picking just one flavor from any one of these menus. While no one here is saying there's anything better than your grandma's secret recipe, sometimes it's good to reach outside the family tree for a special treat.
Ready for you mouth to water? Here are 12 places where you can get an unforgettable pie:
1. Dolce Delight, Ithaca
An amazing place in Ithaca to stop and grab breakfast, this cafe is filled with the creations of a passionate baker! So much more than just the perfect breakfast spot. Our suggestion? Try the Rhubarb Pie!
Location: 1080 Danby Road Ithaca, NY 14850
2. Monica's Pies, Naples
If there's any place on our pie list that you've previously heard of, it's most likely this one. With a flavorful wine region like the Finger Lakes, how could a tasty Grape Pie not make it onto our list?
Location: 7599 NY-21 Naples, NY 14512
3. Briermere Farms, Riverhead
You may end up standing amongst a crowd to get to these pies, popular and full of fresh flavor, Briermere Farms knows how to win over the hearts and stomachs of our residents! Our suggestion? Be sure to grab a Peach Pie!
Location: 4414 Sound Avenue Riverhead, NY 11901
4. Grandma's Pies and Restaurant, Albany
If you can't get your hands on one of your actual grandma's pies, then the next best thing to do is to go to a place called Grandma's...right? Of course! Located in the Capital Region, this scrumptious restaurant was established back in 1976 and has been pumping out amazing pies ever since! Our suggestion? Spoil yourself with the Banana Split Cream Pie that you can see pictured above!
Location: 1273 Central Avenue Albany, NY 12205
5. Pittsford Farms Dairy, Pittsford
Well-known for their ice cream, grabbing one of these incredible pies will please your sweet tooth as well! Our suggestion? Grab a pie to split with the family and pick up some milk to wash it all down!
Location: 44 North Main Street Pittsford, NY 14534
6. Picasso's Pastries and Cafe, Syracuse
Ready to have your taste buds rumble? The sweet aroma of Picasso's will have you wanting to bring home more than just pies! Above you can see pictured one of their dreamy Banana Cream Pies, yum!
Location: 466 Westcott Street Syracuse, NY 13210
7. Brio's Pizzeria & Restaurant, Phoenicia
So, I know we said this post wasn't going to be about pizza but it just so happens that some of the best pies you'll find inside our state come from this little pizzeria! Located near Esopus Creek in the Catskills, you won't go wrong with choosing any one of these exquisite pies!
Location: 68 Main Street Phoenicia, NY 12464
8. Youngs Farm, Glen Head
A true gift to our Long Island residents, this unforgettable farm and bakery shop has some of the absolute best pies you'll ever taste in New York. Consistently fresh, there's not many places full of charm and flavor like this amazing farm is!
Location: 91 Hegemans Lane Glen Head, NY 11545
9. Two Old Tarts, Andes
Located within a small town of the Catskills, this warm and inviting bakery has some delicious sweets waiting for you inside! With a wonderful variety of picturesque pies that are almost too good looking to eat, almost, you'll need a team of friends to help you decide which one to choose. Who knows, maybe you'll leave with more than one kind!
Location: 22 Lee Lane Andes, NY 13731
10. Leo's Bakery and Deli, East Rochester
Crust that is made from scratch and will have you wondering if someone's sneaked your grandma back into their kitchen, Leo's will never disappoint! Our suggestion? Try the Chocolate Cream Pie or the Hi-Apple Pie!
Location: 101 Despatch Drive East Rochester, NY 14445
11. Ithaca Bakery, Ithaca
With so many amazing gems throughout Ithaca, it's no surprise that the Ithaca Bakery made its way onto our list! A spot filled with endless drool-provoking treats, you won't regret stopping into this memorable spot of the Finger Lakes.
Location: 400 North Meadow Street Ithaca, NY 14850
12. Elm Street Bakery, East Aurora
Whether you're stopping in here to start your morning off right with a heavenly breakfast pastry or you're coming by for a heartier meal later in the day, one thing we know for sure is that you should never leave here without a pie!
Location: 72 Elm Street East Aurora, NY 14052
Are you realizing now that it would've been a good idea to put a bib on before you started reading this? Where's your favorite place to get a pie in New York and don't forget to mention your favorite flavor!
Subscribe to our newsletter
Get the latest updates and news
Thank you for subscribing!
