A restaurant doesn't need to look fancy to offer fantastic food. In fact, some of the best restaurants in New Jersey are easy to pass by. There are so many hidden gems throughout the state, but here are a few favorites with rave reviews.
1. Belmont Tavern, 12 Bloomfield Ave., Belleville
This local Italian restaurant is famous for its Chicken Savoy. It may just be a simple brick building, but the food is anything but basic.
2. Seagraves Steak & Submarine, 1 S Tilbury Rd., Salem
You won't find a sign on this small shop, but you will find some of the best subs in New Jersey. Their cheesesteak gives Philly a run for its money.
3. White Manna, 358 River St., Hackensack
This tiny shop has just a few seats, but it offers greasy burgers made to order. The sliders are addictive and affordable.
4. White House Sub Shop, 2301 Arctic Ave., Atlantic City
This historic eatery offers mouthwatering subs and quirky memorabilia like a towel Frank Sinatra once used.
5. Little Negril, 2442 Route 38, Cherry Hill
This authentic Caribbean eatery offers a flavorful taste of the islands. You'll find a wide selection of Jamaican sodas, meat patties and main dishes. You can even buy their sauces to take home with you.
6. Little Shop Of Pizza, 723 B Main Street, Lumberton
Little Shop Of Horrors fans will love Little Shop Of Pizza. They offer great deals like 99-cent cheese slices and have so much more than just pie.
7. Rutt's Hut, 417 River Road, Clifton
New Jersey hot dogs are in a league of their own, but this unassuming spot always comes out on top. A dining landmark, they are famous for their deep-fried rippers, featured on the Food Network, Travel Channel and more.
8. Sammy's Cider Mill & Steakhouse, 353 Mendham Road West (Route 24), Mendham
This unique restaurant was once a speakeasy and serves food a bit differently. You order your food at the counter when you walk in and then head down to the basement bar while you wait. Definitely try the lobster.
9. The County Seat, 62 Water Street
(Route 206 South),
Newton
Head to this eatery with "no curb appeal" for its delicious American fare. They have a varied menu with something for everyone, full bar and authentic Irish coffee.
If You Only Have One Day to Visit This Small Town in Maine, Here’s Everything You Absolutely Can’t Miss
If You Only Have One Day to Visit This Small Town in Massachusetts, Here’s Everything You Absolutely Can’t Miss
If You Only Have One Day to Visit This Small Town in Maryland, Here’s Everything You Absolutely Can’t Miss
10. Laico's, 67 Terhune Ave., Jersey City
This homey Italian eatery is a community staple with delicious dishes like the shrimp stuffed crab over pasta in clam sauce (pictured).
For other unassuming spots in New Jersey, check out these 12 tiny restaurants. For a more luxurious dining experience, check out the most expensive restaurant in the Garden State.
Subscribe to our newsletter
Get the latest updates and news
Thank you for subscribing!