Wood-fired pizza, once a novelty in these parts, is pretty common these days, and I am here for it. But once in a while, you happen upon a slice that is pretty darn exceptional. It was on a whim that a friend and I first decided to stop at the charming little vine-covered pizzeria that I had passed by many times on my way to camp at Lopez Lake or on a road trip through Central Coast. After that first trip, Palo Mesa Wood Fired in Arroyo Grande became one of the main reasons I visited the town.
First of all, how cute is this place? You wouldn’t think that a tiny family-owned spot in a quiet (but lovely!) little town would gain more than local attention, but Palo Mesa Pizza has won regional, national, and international awards! In fact, the owner and chef has represented America at pizza competitions in Italy.
Palo Mesa has three other pizzerias in the area, but the concept at Palo Mesa Wood Fired in the Arroyo Grande Village is unique, and the menu is crave-worthy - “traditional Napoletan pizza with a California twist.”
It’s hard to even say which is my favorite pizza, especially when I see something new on the Palo Mesa Pizza menu to try. On my most recent visit, I went back to basics with the Margherita Pizza. Some might think of this classic as boring, but this one is anything but. First of all, everything is so fresh, from the soft mozzarella to the tomatoes and veggies used. And then there is the crust - the perfectly bubbly, slightly scorched, crispy, chewy, foldable, addictive crust.
Another pizza I love here is also deceptively simple. The Bianca has a divine combination of garlic, mozzarella, basil, parmesan, and sea salt with olive oil (no red sauce). Absolute chef’s kiss. The Verdura, with Sundry tomatoes, artichokes, and balsamic, is also amazing, as is the Nuovo Anno with its pear, pancetta, and gorgonzola toppings. I actually haven’t tasted anything here that wasn’t worth coming back for.
Every time I go, I try to take a good photo but I am so eager to dig in that I have never managed to get a pic of an untouched pizza. Oh, well. I guess that tells you how much I love it. And, as you can see, sometimes I restrain myself from devouring the entire thing so I can have it again the next day… sometimes.
Have you ever been to Palo Mesa Wood Fired in Arroyo Grande Village? If not, I’d say you have a great reason to head that way soon! You can find out more about the menu (as well as menus from the other locations) on the Palo Mesa Pizza website. If you are planning a little getaway to the area - like I do whenever I can - and need a place to stay, check out this gorgeous little beachside Airbnb guest house that’s within walking distance of the Village and just a 5-minute drive from the beach.
Do you have a favorite hidden gem restaurant you’d recommend to your fellow readers? Why not nominate it for a chance to be featured on Only In Your State?
Subscribe to our newsletter
Get the latest updates and news
Thank you for subscribing!